The more I think about it, I sort of agree with ya'll on Joe - he hasn't exactly been as dynamic as I think an A probably deserves. However, with his load and expectations, I'm not sure he could ever earn a real A in many people's eyes - he's not Jordan and he's not Lebron. However, I do see where ya'll are coming from.
As far as Josh, his grade was dropped to C- because of how correctable his mistakes are. He's not simply missing shots - which would just be bad luck (a simple shooting slump). He continues to take shots that he shouldn't, and seemingly playing off every few games (or even more often than that). Furthermore, his free throw percentage is simply mind-boggling.
That's where we were coming from on the grades...
But it is great to hear from you guys, keep the opinions coming!