Question... In Atlanta's pro sports history, are there sportsmen who played somewhere else before coming here, then, upon arrival in Atlanta, either became superstars or enhanced their star-worthy notoriety to the effect that attendance increased and remained high for years? (**)
I ask this because I'm admittedly a bit of a skeptic about the whole "CP3 will electrify the city!" mantra.
Drafted players (Vick, Dale) and other rookies who started here (Nique) pumped some life into stale franchises, and I don't doubt that if we hadn't screwed up the draft, either CP3 or D-Will would be as synonymous with ATL sports as a red #7 football jersey. But now that Paul has earned his national notoriety as part of "somebody else's franchise," I don't foresee a net effect of local excitement translating into packed arenas... at least, not until AFTER he shows he can carry a team to a conference trophy or something.
A few more basketball-purist afficionados would get to Philips more often, sure. And jersey sales couldn't help but go up (Hawks jerseys have their own aisle in the discount corner of Ross Stores these days). But if after adding him (and subtracting other talent to get him) this franchise doesn't get any further in the playoffs, that "new car smell" would wear very fast, no matter what a swell guy he would be locally. "Another second round exit? Heck, we did all this with (Smoove/Horf/Joe) here!", "Deron would've been better anyway!", and all the woe-is-us local media and fan blather would ensue.
It's certainly unfair to see him as a failure as a draw in New Orleans, what with the recovery and all. The Hornets did rise to 8th overall in % attendance the season after they won their division and got to the semifinals (2009), and they were dead-last pre-Katrina (and pre-Paul). But early last season, they were just several thousand unsold tickets away from being able to pack up and relocate to KC, despite Paul being there for 40 games. He's certainly the key reason the franchise was salvaged in the Big Easy. But his presence amid even a couple decent seasons were not "electric" enough to either keep the undersized New Orleans Arena full or keep the Hornets as a sustainable, profitable venture for its ownership or any prospective buyers.
I just don't see the "Fish That Saved Pittsburgh"(***) vibe happening here, not with him alone, anyway.
(**) I gotta rule out Mutombo since they remained near last in the league in attendance despite 56 wins and a DPOY award, although they got some of the bump they needed (up to 13th) the next season, after they drew MJ's Bulls in the second round. As a Yankee-turned-Brave, Deion was kind of a baseball star, but primarily due to the two-sport thing he had going on for a minute. Maddux surely went from All-Star to HOF legend upon arrival from the Cubs. But the Braves had already been through the worst-to-first story and two World Series before he got here, and was already at the top of the NL in attendance by then.
(***) not the best analogy, I know since it was on like 20 times on NBATV this fall... "Moses Guthrie" was already on the team before the "Pisces" renaissance occurred. But I'm thinking of an effect where the team goes from "laughingstock, ennui, and irrelevance" to "mania, packed houses, and triumph."
~lw3