IT STILL COMES DOWN TO...

[Ikeatlanta]

Marvin Williams vs. Josh Smith. Who is the long term small forward for this franchise because if it was Al Horford vs. Josh Smith for the PF spot, ASG and Atlanta fans would let Josh walk in a heartbeat. So if Josh Smith does not get resigned watch out for a long term Marvin Williams contract pretty soon, but if Smith resigns Marvin williams is definitely getting traded only on the grounds that Al Horford cannot play center the rest of his career and we can't pay all three of them. As for Childress he is pretty much in limbo, if Smith returns he's gone. If Smith goes he is retained.

[Peoriabird]

Quote:

---

Marvin Williams vs. Josh Smith. Who is the long term small forward for this franchise because if it was Al Horford vs. Josh Smith for the PF spot, ASG and Atlanta fans would let Josh walk in a heartbeat. So if Josh Smith does not get resigned watch out for a long term Marvin Williams contract pretty soon, but if Smith resigns Marvin williams is definitely getting traded only on the grounds that Al Horford cannot play center the rest of his career and we can't pay all three of them. As for Childress he is pretty much in limbo, if Smith returns he's gone. If Smith goes he is retained.

You have no idea of what you are talking about!

[Frenzy]

Quote:

---

Quote:

---

Marvin Williams vs. Josh Smith. Who is the long term small forward for this franchise because if it was Al Horford vs. Josh Smith for the PF spot, ASG and Atlanta fans would let Josh walk in a heartbeat. So if Josh Smith does not get resigned watch out for a long term Marvin Williams contract pretty soon, but if Smith resigns Marvin williams is definitely getting traded only on the grounds that Al Horford cannot play center the rest of his career and we can't pay all three of them. As for Childress he is pretty much in limbo, if Smith returns he's gone. If Smith goes he is retained.

You have no idea of what you are talking about! really he doesnt,probably thinking too much

[Ikeatlanta]

So explain what exactly dosen't make sense to you. Looks simple to me

[HawkNJersey]

I don't think Al is better PF than Smoove now, nor will ever be.

[Ikeatlanta]

Ya just like Sund is right now. You guys are all worried about Josh Smith, but am more worried about having enough $ to extend Horford and resign Joe Johnson. Those two are the closest being to championship caliber players we have on our roster

[Frenzy]

Quote:

---

So explain what exactly dosen't make sense to you. Looks simple to me

One thing i disagree with is the Chilldress- Smith thing but thats about it,i think we can keep both.

[Peoriabird]

Quote:

---

So explain what exactly dosen't make sense to you. Looks simple to me

Josh Smith is not a Small forward! The two positions require different skill sets!

[Ikeatlanta]

Wow. I love smoove but am not going to start that argument if we take a fan poll saying signing Josh Smith now will cost of the opportunity to extend Horford I am pretty sure the majority would let smith run

[Chris18]

Until we can get a center that is better than Al he should be kept there. If your going to have Josh vs. Marvin at SF Marvin wins everytime because he is a pure SF while Josh is a PF.

[Ikeatlanta]

Ok so if he is not a small forward the position you have him playing is already being occupied by one Al Horford so who do you keep when Al's extension comes up. Unless you have made up your mind that Al is our franchise center?

[HawkNJersey]

Quote:

---

Ok so if he is not a small forward the position you have him playing is already being occupied by one Al Horford so who do you keep when Al's extension comes up. Unless you have made up your mind that Al is our franchise center?

Sund has, and already said so...publicly...

[Ikeatlanta]

I am not reluctant to leaving Al at center, but can we finally afford all three then extend Joe which is the absolute #1 prority for this franchise when that time comes