Josh Smith for Al Jefferson

[BudBall]

I would do it much more beef than Horford down low. Right now this current Smith and Horford down low doesnt work in the playoffs. We need some change.

[coachx]

People talk like this is cut and dry. They're pretty much equal players. But one is more of a defensive player and the other is an offensive one. Smoove is more athletic and active, Jefferson is more fundamentally sound.

The main feature that Jefferson has over Smoove, is that he's 20 lbs heavier and can play both C and PF.

The main feature that Smoove has over Jefferson, is that he's arguably one of the fastest PFs in the game.

For the regular season, Smoove is better. For the playoffs, Jefferson's style may be best.

I totally agree with that.

Its not about who is the best player. Its about who is the best fit on your team.

Edited July 2, 2010 by coachx

[AHF]

People talk like this is cut and dry. They're pretty much equal players. But one is more of a defensive player and the other is an offensive one. Smoove is more athletic and active, Jefferson is more fundamentally sound.

I can understand the argument it is even on the court. How do the off-the-court issues not creep in here because makes it a no-brainer, IMO!