Who are the best three pf's in this group?

[Mutombolievable]

Ok team, it's Friday, I'm running on empty, and I wanted to ask you guys a quick question.

Based on these 2012-2013 season stats, who are the top 3 pf's out of this group? Just your personal opinion. I am sure some of you will know who the players are but if you dont, please don't look them up. I'm just curious.

Are these players pretty close to being on the same level?

Player 1 - 18.6 ppg, 8.7 rebs, 3.7 assists, .7 blocks, 1.4 steals - 23.86 PERPlayer 2 - 17.1 ppg, 8.6 rebs, 4.2 assists, 2 blocks, 1.2 steals - 17.19 PER

Player 3 - 17.4 ppg, 10 rebs, 3.3 assists, 1.2 blocks, 1 steal - 20.19 PER

Player 4 - 18.9 ppg, 11.3 rebs, 3.8 assists, .3 blocks, .9 steals - 19.43 PER

Player 5 - 15.7 ppg, 11.6 rebs, 1.5 assists, .5 blocks, .8 steals - 18.15 PER

Edited March 8, 2013 by Mutombolievable

[yungsta]

I would take player 4 but it would help alot if you could also post their FG% and TOs too.

[coachx]

I would take player 4 but it would help alot if you could also post their FG% and TOs too.

Can't make a decision without FG%.

The difference in a 45% FG PF and a 52% FG PF is a pretty drastic difference.

[Mutombolievable]

Good point. How can I go back up and put these next to each player?

Player 1 - 55% FG, 2.3 TO

Player 2 - 46% FG, 3.1 TO

Player 3 - 56% FG, 2.0 TO

Player 4 - 51% FG, 2.7 TO

Player 5 - 46% FG, 2.1 TO

Looking back I wish I had done a "rank them" poll (if that's even possible)

[OGRat]

Also I would like to know what type of game they play. Do they play in the low post or out on the perimeter.

[yungsta]

Good point. How can I go back up and put these next to each player?

Player 1 - 55% FG, 2.3 TO

Player 2 - 46% FG, 3.1 TO

Player 3 - 56% FG, 2.0 TO

Player 4 - 51% FG, 2.7 TO

Player 5 - 46% FG, 2.1 TO

Looking back I wish I had done a "rank them" poll (if that's even possible)

mmmmm I might change my vote to player 3 then. Highest FG% double double, lowest TO rate.

[coachx]

Good point. How can I go back up and put these next to each player?

Player 1 - 55% FG, 2.3 TO

Player 2 - 46% FG, 3.1 TO

Player 3 - 56% FG, 2.0 TO

Player 4 - 51% FG, 2.7 TO

Player 5 - 46% FG, 2.1 TO

Looking back I wish I had done a "rank them" poll (if that's even possible)

Well that makes it easy. I don't want a PF shooting 46% when I can have one shooting 55%. Funny the guy with the lowest FG% also has the highest turnovers. He must have a decision making / shot selection issue !

Edited March 8, 2013 by coachx

[Theeyo]

im pretty sure #2 is Smoove * #3 is Horford

[Watchman]

im pretty sure #2 is Smoove * #3 is Horford

I believe you are correct, sir.

[Mutombolievable]

im pretty sure #2 is Smoove * #3 is Horford

Well done. Care to take a stab at 1,4, and 5?

[ATLien_]

I figured out Al and Josh too. Even before I saw Fg percentage and turns. That additional info made it too easy. My guesses for the others.1) David Lee4) Lamarcus Aldridge5) Zach Randolph

Edited March 9, 2013 by ATLien_

[capstone21]

1. Blake Griffen

4. David Lee

5. Zach Randolph

[Mutombolievable]

1. Blake Griffen

4. David Lee

5. Zach Randolph

You got it. 3 Western All-Stars and Al got the most votes. Let's move to the Western Conference and keep the big lineup. Love that Al got the most votes.