ranking the NFL QBs

[cyman3]

http://www.fannation.com/blogs/post/14552?cnn=yes

(in order)

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Carson Palmer

Drew Brees

Philip Rivers

Donovan McNabb

Ben Roethlisberger

Marc Bulger

Matt Hasselbeck

Michael Vick

Tony Romo

Matt Leinart

Jay Cutler

Vince Young

Brett Favre

Steve McNair

Alex Smith

Jeff Garcia

Jake Delhomme

Chad Pennington

Jon Kitna

Eli Manning

Damon Huard

Trent Green (assuming he's a Dolphin)

Jason Campbell

Rex Grossman

Byron Leftwich

J.P. Losman

Matt Schaub

Josh McCown

Tarvaris Jackson

Charlie Frye

[shug94]

I would move Hasslebeck up a spot, and Cutler down a couple.

But otherwise this is pretty good.

[Plainview1981]

Quote:

---

I would move Hasslebeck up a spot, and Cutler down a couple.

But otherwise this is pretty good.

---

Quote:

---

I would move Hasslebeck up a spot, and Cutler down a couple.

But otherwise this is pretty good.

---

Grossman better than Byron Leftwich? Byron isn't great, but Grossman is possibly the worst QB in the league. He turns the ball over 3 or 4 times a game it seems like. It also doesn't seem like he can make good throws inside of 10 yards either.

Grossman has really poor fundamentals and I can't understand why he keeps getting to start and a guy like McNabb could be pushed out of a starting spot.

Makes no sense. Grossman has very little talent.

Why is Big Ben so high? He didn't do anything last year. Vick is too high... Vince Young was better than him last year. Jeff Garcia is too low...

This is how I'd list them:

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Carson Palmer

Drew Brees

Donovan McNabb

Phil Rivers

Matt Hasselback

Marc Bulger

Chad Pennington

Jeff Garcia

Eli Manning

Tony Romo

Big Ben

Jay Cutler

Vince Young

Mike Vick

Alex Smith

Brett Farve

Steve McNair

Matt Leinert

Byron Leftwich

Jake Delhome

Jon Kitna

Trent Green

jason Campbell

Damon Huard

Charlie Frye

J.P Losman

Matt Schaub

Josh McCown

Tarvaris Jackson

Rex Grossman

[Plainview1981]

I've always liked QB's like Jeff Garcia and Mark Brunell because they're the medium between a Mike Vick and a Tom Brady. Rich Gannon was another one.

[cyman3]

Quote:

---

Grossman is possibly the worst QB in the league.

---

you have to keep in mind. HALF the games he played SUPER WELL and other half he played like a 3rd string QB.

[Plainview1981]

Quote:

---

Quote:

---

Grossman is possibly the worst QB in the league.

---

you have to keep in mind. HALF the games he played SUPER WELL and other half he played like a 3rd string QB.

---

3 String? Maybe AFL worthy. He had some really, really, bad games. I think he had a couple of games with like a 10 or 20 passer rating.