Who will be the better player? 5

[Diesel]

New Series I'm starting. Who will be better. I'm talking over a career. Yes, it's all guesswork, but I think the comparisons will be interesting.

Edited August 5, 2009 by Diesel

[coachx]

New Series I'm starting. Who will be better. I'm talking over a career. Yes, it's all guesswork, but I think the comparisons will be interesting.

This is definately the toughest one of them all.

I have no idea.

[Diesel]

This is definately the toughest one of them all.

I have no idea.

I tried to make them all tough and reasonable. I think the toughest is Smoove vs. Beasley. Simply because Beasley will always get that opportunity to be the 2nd man. Smoove has had to work for his and he's still not it.

But when you put Marvin up against other Sfs.... yeah, it gets tough... and all of these guys came after him.

[AHF]

Randolph is a PF and a dynamic one. I voted for him.

That said, he is the one of this bunch that is not like the others.

[capstone21]

Randolph is a PF and a dynamic one. I voted for him.

That said, he is the one of this bunch that is not like the others.

I am a Marvin fan but I think Jeff Green is going to be a special player.

[ConverseChris]

I think Thad will be an All-Star in a year or 2 and will be the best out of the bunch.

[exodus]

I think Young is an easy call here over Green and Marvin. Randolph doesnt even play the same position so i don't see how he is relevant.

[EazyRoc]

I think Young will be the better of the group. He's got the ability to score all over the court, and he's a solid rebounder.

[Joker]

Marvin

[HawkItus]

I picked Marvin with one caveat being if he will be allowed to be a 1st or 2nd option during his career.